Back/Test Strips: Pros, Cons & When to Use Them

Test Strips: Pros, Cons & When to Use Them

Understand the tradeoffs between test strips and liquid test kits so you can make informed decisions about pool testing.

When to use: Deciding whether test strips are sufficient for your pool, or considering upgrading to a liquid test kit.
Quick turn
#testing#beginner#education#accuracy

Test Strips: The Honest Truth

Understand the real tradeoffs so you can choose the right testing method for your pool.

TL;DR - The Bottom Line

Test strips are fast and convenient but inaccurate (±0.5-1 ppm error). They work for hot tubs and quick checks, but fail for troubleshooting, SLAM, or CYA-stabilized pools. Liquid test kits cost more upfront but save money long-term through better chemistry control.

Recommendation: If you actively manage your pool chemistry, invest in a Taylor K-2006 kit ($60-80). If you just want to verify chlorine before swimming, strips might be sufficient.

1

What Are Test Strips?

Test strips are plastic strips with chemical pads that change color when dipped in pool water.

Paper or plastic strip with 4-7 chemical pads that react to different parameters
Most common tests: FC/TC, pH, TA, CH, CYA (sometimes salt or hardness)
Color changes occur within 15-30 seconds of dipping
Results are read by matching colors to a chart printed on the bottle
Sold in bottles of 25-100 strips, typically $15-25 per bottle
Each strip is single-use and tests multiple parameters at once
Key Takeaways
  • • Test strips are NOT the same as 'pool store water tests' - those often use liquid reagents on professional equipment
  • • Different brands have different accuracy levels - price doesn't always correlate with quality
  • • Aquachek and Taylor are the most common brands, but even these vary by product line
2

The Advantages: Speed & Convenience

Test strips excel in situations where rough ballpark numbers are sufficient.

Speed

Dip, wait 15 seconds, read. Total time: 30 seconds vs. 5-10 minutes for liquid tests.

Simplicity

No bottles to juggle, no drop counting, no tubes to rinse. Perfect for quick checks.

Low Initial Cost

$15-25 gets you started immediately vs. $60-80 for a Taylor K-2006 kit.

Portability

Fits in your pocket. Great for hot tubs, vacation homes, or service calls.

Multi-Parameter

One strip tests 5-7 parameters at once - helpful for broad overview.

No Mixing Required

No reagents to expire, no bottles to spill, no mess to clean up.

Key Takeaways
  • • Test strips shine for hot tubs where water volume is small and precision matters less
  • • Great for pool service pros who need quick yes/no answers on 20+ pools per day
  • • Ideal for 'sniff test' before guests arrive: Is chlorine present? Is pH in range?
3

The Critical Limitations

Test strips have accuracy problems that can cost you hundreds in wasted chemicals or missed algae blooms.

Poor Accuracy (±0.5-1.0 ppm error)

Strips often read FC within ±1 ppm. If your target is 5 ppm and strip says 6, actual FC could be 5-7 ppm. This matters when trying to maintain FC/CYA ratio.

Impact: Critical issue for SLAM, FC/CYA ratios, or low FC detection

Narrow Color Ranges

Most strips max out at FC 10 ppm. During SLAM (FC 20-40+ ppm), strips are useless. CYA strips often cap at 100-150 ppm.

Impact: Cannot monitor SLAM progress or high CYA situations accurately

Color Matching Subjectivity

Is that orange closer to 7.2 or 7.4? Lighting, color blindness, and interpretation vary person-to-person.

Impact: Two people testing same water may get different readings

Reagent Degradation

Pads lose potency when exposed to air, moisture, heat, or sunlight. Bottle says 2-year shelf life, but accuracy drops after 6 months if not stored perfectly.

Impact: Old strips give false low readings, leading to over-chlorination

No Combined Chlorine (CC) Test

Most strips show Total Chlorine, not FC specifically. You can't detect chloramines or assess sanitation quality.

Impact: Miss early algae warnings or chloramine buildup

Temperature Sensitivity

Strips are calibrated for 80°F water. Cold or hot water skews results by 0.2-0.5 pH or 1-2 ppm FC.

Impact: Seasonal inaccuracy in spring/fall or heated pools

Key Takeaways
  • • The biggest danger: Strips give false confidence. You think you're at 5 ppm FC, but you're actually at 3 ppm and algae blooms.
  • • Strips cannot replace liquid tests for troubleshooting or precision chemistry management
4

Real-World Failure Scenarios

Here's where test strips lead pool owners astray in actual practice.

Scenario: The False Security Algae Bloom
Problem: Strip shows FC at 5 ppm (good!). You relax. Three days later, pool is green.
Reality: Actual FC was 2 ppm (strip read high due to old reagents). Algae started growing but you didn't catch it early.
Solution: Liquid test would have shown true 2 ppm, prompting immediate FC boost.
Scenario: The SLAM Failure
Problem: Trying to SLAM with CYA at 50 (target FC 20 ppm). Strip maxes out at 10 ppm, says 'high chlorine.'
Reality: You have no idea if FC is 12, 18, or 25 ppm. Can't monitor SLAM progress or know when to stop adding chlorine.
Solution: Taylor K-2006 FC test goes to 50+ ppm with dilution - essential for SLAM.
Scenario: The High CYA Miss
Problem: Strip shows CYA at 100 ppm (top of scale). You think you're borderline but okay.
Reality: Actual CYA is 150 ppm. You need to partially drain, but strip can't tell you that.
Solution: Taylor CYA test accurately measures 30-200+ ppm, prompting proper action.
Scenario: The pH Drift
Problem: Strip shows pH at 7.6 (perfect!). But your plaster is etching or you're getting scale.
Reality: pH is actually 7.9 (strip read low). CSI is positive and you're depositing calcium or your TA is low and pH is crashing to 7.2.
Solution: Liquid pH test to 0.2 precision reveals the drift, letting you correct TA or add acid.
Scenario: The Cost Trap
Problem: Strips are cheap! $20 for 50 strips, lasts all summer.
Reality: Testing 2x/week = 8/month = 32/season. You need 2 bottles ($40). Missed algae bloom costs $100 in shock + $50 in clarifier + 3 days of labor. Poor FC control wastes $200 in excess chlorine.
Solution: Taylor kit: $70 upfront, lasts 2+ seasons with $15/year refills. Saves hundreds in prevented problems.
Key Takeaways
  • • The common thread: Strips give you 80% accuracy, which sounds good until that 20% error costs you a week of work and $300 in chemicals
5

When Test Strips Are 'Good Enough'

Let's be fair - there ARE situations where test strips make sense.

✅ When Test Strips Work Well:
Hot Tubs & Spas

Smaller water volume, more frequent draining, less precision needed. Quick pH/chlorine check before use is sufficient.

Secondary Quick Checks

You own a liquid test kit for weekly detailed tests, but want a fast strip check mid-week to confirm chlorine hasn't crashed.

Pool Service Route Work

Testing 20-30 pools per day. Strips give fast triage - flag problem pools for liquid re-test.

Vacation/Rental Properties

Pool is professionally maintained, but you want guests to verify safe swim conditions. Strips answer 'Is chlorine present?' adequately.

Absolute Beginners (First 2 Weeks)

Learning pool ownership. Strips give rough baseline before investing in Taylor kit. But upgrade quickly!

Very Stable, Simple Pools

Small above-ground pool, minimal use, no CYA, liquid chlorine only. Less to go wrong, so rough numbers work.

❌ When You Need Liquid Tests:
Troubleshooting Chemistry Problems

Cloudy water? Algae? Scaling? You need precise readings to diagnose root cause. Strips will mislead you.

SLAM Process

Impossible. You cannot monitor FC above 10 ppm or track overnight chlorine loss accurately.

High CYA Pools (50+ ppm)

FC/CYA ratio is critical. Strip inaccuracy of ±1 ppm means you can't maintain proper FC target.

New Plaster/Startup

pH control is critical in first 30 days. Strips' ±0.2-0.4 pH error risks plaster damage or staining.

Saltwater Pools (SWG)

Need to track CYA buildup, monitor FC/CYA ratio, and verify cell output. Strips lack precision for this.

Long-Term Cost Savings

Strips seem cheap but cost more over 2+ years vs. liquid kit, AND lead to expensive chemistry mistakes.

Key Takeaways
  • • Rule of thumb: If you check your pool less than 1x/week or treat it like a black box, strips might work. If you actively manage chemistry, you need liquid tests.
6

Cost Comparison: Strips vs. Liquid Test Kits

Let's do the math on what you actually spend over time.

Test Strips (Aquachek 7-in-1)
Upfront: $20-25
Per Test: $0.40-0.50/strip
Annual: $40-50 (2 bottles for 2x/week testing = ~100 strips/season)
2-Year: $80-100
Hidden Costs:

Wasted chemicals from inaccurate readings: $100-300/year. Algae bloom recovery (1x): $150-300.

True Total: $330-700 over 2 years
Taylor K-2006 Liquid Test Kit
Upfront: $60-80
Per Test: $0.10-0.15/test (FC+pH only, most common)
Annual: $15-20 (refill R-0001, R-0003 reagents for ~200 tests)
2-Year: $95-120
Hidden Costs:

Prevents algae blooms via early FC detection: saves $150-300. Optimized chemical use: saves $100-200/year.

True Total: $0-$120 over 2 years (savings offset cost, or net negative cost)
Verdict:

Liquid test kits pay for themselves in Year 1 through prevented problems and optimized chemical use. Strips look cheap but cost 3-6x more when accounting for hidden costs.

Key Takeaways
  • • If cost is the ONLY concern, buy a basic FC/pH liquid tester ($25-30) instead of strips. Gives accuracy where it matters most.
  • • Many pool owners buy strips, struggle with algae, then buy liquid kit anyway. Skip the intermediate failure and buy liquid upfront.
7

How to Use Test Strips Correctly (If You Choose Them)

If you're sticking with strips, at least use them properly to minimize errors.

Store strips in cool, dark, dry place - never in pool shed or bathroom (moisture ruins them)
Check expiration date - discard strips older than 1 year even if bottle says 2 years
Dip strip elbow-deep in pool (not surface water) and remove immediately - don't swirl
Hold strip LEVEL and still during color development (15 seconds) - tilting causes reagents to run together
Read strip in bright natural light within 15-20 seconds (colors fade quickly)
Match colors to chart at ARM'S LENGTH - don't hold strip directly against bottle (optical illusion skews reading)
Test same time of day for consistency - FC burns off in sunlight, so morning tests are more stable
If strip shows unexpected result (sudden drop/spike), re-test with new strip or use liquid test to confirm
Replace bottle every season even if not empty - reagents degrade over winter storage
Buy smallest bottle size you'll use in 3-4 months - larger bottles seem economical but reagents expire
Key Takeaways
  • • Even perfect technique can't overcome strips' inherent ±0.5-1.0 ppm inaccuracy. Best practices just minimize additional user error.
  • • If you notice your pool having recurring chemistry issues (algae, cloudy water, pH swings), that's your cue to upgrade to liquid tests.
8

Making Your Decision

Honest self-assessment: Which testing method fits YOUR situation?

Do you have algae blooms more than once per year?
Yes:You need liquid test kit for better FC monitoring.
No:Continue to next question.
Is your CYA above 50 ppm (stabilized chlorine or salt pool)?
Yes:You need liquid test kit to maintain proper FC/CYA ratio.
No:Continue to next question.
Do you add chemicals based on test results?
Yes:You need liquid test kit - inaccurate inputs = wasted chemicals.
No:Continue to next question.
Are you willing to spend 5-10 minutes per test for accuracy?
Yes:Liquid test kit is worth the time investment for better results.
No:Continue to next question.
Do you only test to verify 'chlorine is present' before swimming?
Yes:Test strips may be sufficient for basic safety checks (but consider strips + annual liquid test).
No:Continue to next question.
Is this a hot tub, very small pool, or rental property?
Yes:Test strips are acceptable for these lower-stakes situations.
No:Based on your answers, you should invest in a liquid test kit.
Final Recommendation:

For most pool owners with in-ground pools, CYA-stabilized water, and desire to minimize chemical costs: **Liquid test kit is the right choice.** Test strips are a false economy that costs more in the long run through chemistry mistakes and wasted chemicals.

Next Steps

Ready to Upgrade to Liquid Testing?

Check out the "Using Your Taylor Test Kit" playbook for beginner-friendly instructions on mastering the K-2006 kit.

Want to Learn More About Pool Chemistry?

Visit TroubleFreePool.com for comprehensive guides on FC/ CYA ratios, water balance, and the science behind accurate testing.

Still Using Strips?

That's okay! Just be aware of their limitations and consider supplementing with occasional liquid tests (or pool store tests) when troubleshooting problems.

Checklist

  1. 1Understand what test strips are and how they work.
  2. 2Learn the key advantages: speed, convenience, and low initial cost.
  3. 3Recognize the critical limitations: poor accuracy and narrow ranges.
  4. 4See real-world scenarios where test strips fail to catch problems.
  5. 5Understand when test strips are 'good enough' vs. when you need precision.
  6. 6Compare ongoing costs: strips vs. liquid test kits.
  7. 7Learn how to use test strips correctly if you choose to use them.
  8. 8Decide which testing method is right for your situation.

Related Playbooks

Using Your Taylor Test Kit

Master the Taylor K-2006 test kit with step-by-step guidance that descalates the overwhelming complexity for first-time users.

Pool Chemistry 101

Understand the WHY behind every chemical adjustment. The foundation of pool care.

Pool Inventory & Equipment ID

Identify what equipment you have and understand what it does. Essential for inherited pools.